Medieval Guilds Never Inspected What You Think
Here’s the thing that broke my mental model: medieval guilds weren’t actually inspecting finished products. I went into this research expecting to find that guilds were basically the original Yelp reviewers — craftsmen peering at each other’s work, checking seams, testing metal hardness, rejecting shoddy output before it reached customers. The 500-year-old version of a five-star rating system, just slower and conducted by guys in funny hats. That’s the story we tell ourselves about guild quality control, and it’s almost entirely wrong....